|
|
2003:12 Hierarchy as a Strength and Weakness of Communist Rule |
Martin Hájek (ed.) |
|
This volume is comprised of the papers that were presented at the seminar “Hierarchy as a Strength and Weakness of Communist Rule”, which was held on 11-12 September 2003 at the Faculty of Social Sciences of Charles University in Prague. The general purpose of the seminar was to reveal and interpret, in so far as possible without misrepresentation or bias, the procedures on which communist rule of society was based at the end of the 1980s. The papers delivered at the seminar and presented here in this volume can be divided into three thematic groups. The first group is made up of investigations into the methods and strategies of communist rule in general. This refers mainly to the legal framework of this rule, how it fits among the modern forms of government, which are able only with difficulty to separate the political from the economic and which often feature all-encompassing planning ambitions. This group of papers also covers the issue of the character of the rules and orders in “really existing” socialism. The second group is made up of papers devoted to analysing the form of rule at the highest level, the district level and the local level. The final and concluding section is comprised of two papers dealing with the subject of communist rule and individual and collective memory.
Introduction
The mirror of normalisation did not tell the truth about the communist regime. Nor did the transition-period mirror of the Velvet Revolution and the ensuing transformation present a realistic portrait of communist rule. The seminar “Hierarchy as a Strength and Weakness of Communist Rule” attempted to offer truer images of communist rule. The authors believe that it is possible to study some of the key features of modern rule in the communist regime and that the knowledge that can be gained from this will help facilitate a better preparedness and understanding for the battle against the institutionalised irresponsibility that accompanies modern rule.
The main subject of the seminar developed out of one of the goals of the research project “The Legacy of Communist Rule”. That aim was to conduct a sociological study of Czech real socialism that could as much as possible without distortion or bias describe and theoretically pinpoint the procedures lying behind communist control over society (the process of implementing its leading role) at the end of the 1980s. This kind of description was intended to serve as a starting point for the study of the kind of possible shapes the post-revolution persistence of these forms of rule can take.
The authors were interested in the role hierarchies played in the relatively stable institutional functioning of Czech real socialism at the end of the 1980s. They defined government and rule as the execution of authority and otherwise acquired power in hierarchical relationships. In this way the government hierarchically permeates the whole of society from the top down. The application of democratic centralism and the procedures of nomenclature administration rendered hierarchies – despite the declared egalitarianism – at once a means and an end of communist rule. After November 1989, without the Communist Party occupying its exclusive position, these could no longer be applied in their “totality”. Nonetheless, an entire series of indicators suggest that the methods and procedures of rule introduced at an earlier time have, just like a variety of other forms of institutionalised irresponsibility, successfully managed to adjust to meet the new circumstances and are able with relative ease to colonise the newly introduced constitutional forms of rule. The authors believe that this is caused by the fact that communist rule was founded on specific forms of controlling what were originally constitutional institutions, which in the new circumstances could come in useful for a variety of different interest groups. Communism was the place to learn how to rule undemocratically while preserving the façade of democracy.
The seminar was held on 11-12 September 2003 in the main building of the Faculty of Social Sciences of Charles University in Prague, just prior to the conclusion of the grant project (no. 403/01/1564). It served mainly three purposes: it was intended to contribute to furthering international co-operation; to contribute to a critical evaluation of mainly the theoretical work resulting from the project; and to no less a degree to contribute to an open discussion of issues relating to communist rule, which it turn would serve to deepen and specify the summary interpretation of the described methods of rule in Czechoslovak real socialism.
The seminar contributions in this presented in this volume could be loosely divided into three thematic groups. The first group was made up of papers dealing with the general subject of the methods and strategies of communist rule. Jiří Kabele demonstrates how the socialist legal framework provided a support to the execution of state power primarily through the weakening of the importance ascribed to rules-laws and through the considerable strengthening of the significance of sub-legal norms and unwritten rules. There thus emerged an environment that could guarantee the “legal” assertion of the leading role of the Communist Party. Tomáš Holeček describes the commissioning of Party tasks at the regional level of communist government. He underlines some characteristic features of this process, e.g. the repeated issuing of orders to do that which is obligatory anyway, which in the author’s view is a feature common to modern forms of rule in general. Lubomír Mlčoch examines the inverted executive pyramid in the economies of real socialism. The core of his argument is the idea that “the exaggerated ambitiousness of the social experiment in planning and running an entire economy and society led to the inoperativeness of the ‘executive pyramid’ and at a certain stage in the evolution of the system also to the rise of the contradictory – but also actually self-preserving – forces in the inverted ‘executive pyramid’”. Petr Kohútek focuses on the issue of the intertwining of political and economic dimensions of conduct, describing the strategies of the distribution and acquisition of means on the basis of a particular example. Using research studies drawn from the past and the present he draws a parallel between the past strategies used to acquire money “from the state” and today’s strategies of acquiring financial resources from European funds. Jiří Kabele concludes the discussion of the subject of methods and strategies of communist rule with his analysis of communist orders and regulations. Hooking up in part to his previous study in these pages he points to a typical feature of communist orders – the neglect of certain procedural specifications of the relationships within the hierarchy and the space that consequently emerges and is defended for asserting democratic centralism and the communist nomenclature administration.
The second group of texts is devoted to analyses of the strategies of communist government at different levels in the hierarchy. Martin Hájek argues that communist rule at the highest level was actually a double rule – over the Party and society – wherein the attempt to control both at the same time often presented the highest leadership with dilemmas difficult to resolve. For example, the purge in the Party leadership signified also a direct and indirect purge in the highest state organs and vice versa; to do one without the other was simply not possible. Zdena Vajdová focuses on the gradual transformations that the communist rule went through at the district level. This is demonstrated for example by the amount and kind of participants in various Party meetings or the stylistic transformation of speeches and discussion contributions. The role of local and metropolitan national committees and their position in the system of government in real socialism is described by Lukáš Valeš. He discovered that “they were exceptional both in terms of their legal standing, their capacity even to integrate citizens in local administration who otherwise were outside the political structure at that time, and primarily in terms of their material pragmatism in managing districts and towns”. In the author’s view this political pragmatism of the national committees expressed itself fully particularly towards the end of the communist regime. Two other contributions focus on rule and communists in Slovakia. Simon Smith reveals several tendencies in the regime of local rule, which appeared in connection with the new way in which the central and marginal space was organised. The main areas with the dominant industrial enterprises had a tendency to accept the “instrumental” regime, while “organic” regimes were characteristic for the peripheral areas. Nonetheless, according to the author the development of certain areas was still dependent on position within the administrative hierarchy. Josef Kandert examined the position and government of communists in traditional village communities. In his paper he provides a detailed and ethnographically researched description of the structure of the villages studied and the role of the communists within them. He claims that the community was always divided into two rival cliques competing for power, while at the same time it was possible for communists to be represented in both of them.
The concluding section of the volume contains two texts dealing with the relationship between communist rule and collective and individual memory. Françoise Mayer bases her paper on a study of five published testimonies given by former communist functionaries. The author shows how complex and, in the post-communist field, unique a situation the former prominent figures of the communist regime in this country found themselves in and how this is projected in their statements. The author attempts to show how through this testimony, which often takes the form of justifications, we can learn more about the system of political and social values of the people behind them. The essay by Jiřina Šiklová stems from an analysis of the personal past of those who have forgotten or are trying to forget that they sustained communist rule if by no other means then at least by dutifully filling in of cadre questionnaires. The text presents various forms of these “self-evaluations” and their overlooked consequences.
Keywords
Communist rule, real socialism, hierarchy, communist party
|
Hierarchie jako přednost i slabina komunistického vládnutí |
|
|
|
2009:6 The Principles of Partnership and Participation as Applied in Small Towns in the Czech Republic |
2009:5 Social Capital in the Czech Republic and in an International Comparison |
2009:4 The Gender Segregation of the Czech Labour Market. A Quantitative and Qualitative Image |
2009:3 Problem Neighbourhoods in Cities and the Regeneration Policies That Target Them – A Case Study of Prague |
2009:2 Czech Religiosity at the Start of the Third Millennium. Results of the ISSP 2008 – Religion |
2009:1 The First Elections to the Senate. An Analysis of the 1996 Elections to the Senate of the Parliament of the Czech Republic |
2008:5 The Perception and Construction of Social Distance in Czech Society |
2008:4 Social Distances and Stratification: Social Space in the Czech Republic |
2008:3 Evolution and Determination of Educational Inequalities in the Czech Republic between 1955 and 2002 in the European Context |
2008:2 Actors of Local Development - Orlicko |
2008:1 The Political Awareness of Citizens: Theories, Measurements and the Role of Political Awareness in the Study of Political Attitudes |
2007:11 A Permanent or Temporary Change? The Arrangement of Gender Roles in Families with Fathers Participating in Childcare |
2007:10 Participation and Partnership in Local Public Administration |
2007:9 Family Friendly Working Conditions in an International Comparison |
2007:8 The Political Impact of Suburbanisation |
2007:7 Fathers, Mothers and Caring for Children after Divorce |
2007:6 The Foreign Migration of Scientists and Researchers and the Tools for Influencing Migration |
2007:5 The Representation of Different Forms of Family and Working Life in Women’s and Men’s Magazines |
2007:4 Czech Labour Market: Changing Structures and Work Orientations |
2007:3 The Relationship between Changes in the Labour Market and Private, Family and Partnership Life |
2007:2 The Institutional Background of Czech Sociology before the Onset of Marxism |
2007:1 Educational Aspirations in a Comparative Perspective. The role of individual, contextual and structural factors in the formation of educational aspirations in OECD countries |
2006:14 Work and Family Roles and How They Are Combined in the Lives of Czech Parents: Plans versus Reality |
2006:13 The Representation of Parenthood and Childlessness in Selected Women’s and Men’s Magazines |
2006:12 Social Solidarity from the Perspective of the Czech Public |
2006:11 Science as a public matter: science policies and the media |
2006:10 The Issue of Minorities in the Czech Republic: Community Life and the Representation of Collective Interests (Slovaks, Ukrainians, Vietnamese, and Roma) |
2006:9 Social Standing and Lifestyle in Czech Society |
2006:8 The Image of Science in Czech Public Opinion |
2006:7 Social Capital. Concepts, Theories, and Methods of Measurement |
2006:6 Basic Features of the Membership Base of KDU-ČSL |
2006:5 Non-Marital Fertility in the Czech Republic after 1989: The Social and Economic Context |
2006:4 The Phenomenon of Childlessness in a Sociological and Demographic Perspective |
2006:3 Participation, Democracy and Citizenship in a European Context |
2006:2 Autonomy and Cooperation: Effect of the Municipal System Established in 1990 |
2006:1 Socio-economic Values, Policies, and Institutions in the Period of the Czech Republic’s Accession to the European Union |
2005:06 Civil Society in the Regions of the Czech Republic |
2005:05 Civil Society and Civic Participation in the Czech Republic |
2005:04 Work/Life Balance in the Czech Republic: Policy, Time, Money, and Individual, Family, and Company Practices |
2005:03 Regional Elites 2004 |
2005:02 Political Behavior in Metropolitan Areas in the Czech Republic between 1990 and 2002 – Patterns, Trends and the Relation to Suburbanization and Its Socio-Spatial Patterns |
2005:01 Measuring Value Orientations with the Use of S.H. Schwartz’s Value Portraits |
2004:11 The Formation of Group Mentalities in the Czech Republic after 1989 |
2004:10 Hierarchy as the Strength and the Weakness of Communist Rule. The Legacy of Communist Rule IV: A Volume of Papers from the Seminar Held in Prague on September 11-12, 2003 |
2004:9 Czech National Identity after the Break Up Czechoslovakia and before Accession to the European Union |
2004:8 Life Strategies of Businesswomen and Businessmen at the Turn of the Millennium |
2004:7 Attitudes towards Marriage, Parenthood and Family Roles in the Czech Republic and in Europe |
2004:6 Life Satisfaction: Family,Work, and Other Factors |
2004:5 What Faith? Contemporary Czech Religiosity/Spirituality in the Perspective of Qualitative Sociology of Religion |
2004:4 Structural Tensions in the Interface between the Labour Market and Social Policy in the Czech Republic |
2004:3 Metropolitan Areas in the Czech Republic – Definitions, Basic Characteristics, Patterns of Suburbanisation and Their Impact on Political Behaviour |
2004:2 International Violence Against Women Survey – Czech Republic/2003: Sociological Research on Domestic Violence |
2004:1 Elections to the European Parliament in 2004 – An Analysis of Electoral Participation and Party Support in the Czech Republic |
2003:12 Hierarchy as a Strength and Weakness of Communist Rule |
2003:11 How the Czech Public Views the Elites the Political and Economic Elites |
2003:10 The Reconstruction of Communist Rule at the End of the 1980s |
2003:9 Women’s Civic and Political Participation in the Czech Republic and the Role of European Union Gender Equality and Accession Policies |
2003:8 Pre-election polls, election results, and validity of measurement before the 2002 elections |
2003:7 Party Preference Surveys, Their Application in Society and the Issue of Quality |
2003:6 The Transformations of Czech Socio-economic Values at the Turn of the Century |
2003:5 Objective and Subjective Assessments of the Financial Accessibility of Housing in the Czech Republic during the 1990s |
2003:4 Entry into Marriage and Unmarried Cohabitation in the Czech Republic since 1989 in Connection with Education |
2003:3 Work and Job Values in CEE and EU countries |
2003:2 Intergenerational Biographic Configurations of the Inhabitants of the NISA Euroregion |
2003:1 Structurally Generated Growth of Inequality |
2002:13 Public Opinion Surveys – Theoretical Aspects and Practical Application |
2002:12 Group Mentalities |
2002:11 The World of Hierarchies and Real Socialism. The legacy of communist rule II: volume of contributions investigating of social hierarchies |
2002:10 Social Context of the Lives of Women Working in Management Positions |
2002:09 Parties in the Parliament. Why, When and How do Parties act in Unity? |
2002:08 Life strategies of women managers: case study |
2002:07 Region and Politics |
2002:06 The World of Hierarchies and Really Existing Socialism |
2002:05 Housing Careers in the Czech Republic 1960 - 2001 |
2002:04 Re-emigrants and Socially Shared Values |
2002:03 Satisfaction with Housing among the Czech Population |
2002:02 The Family Origin on the Evolution of Educational Inequalities in the Czech Republic after 1989 |
2002:01 The Rise and Evolution of the New Elites in the Czech Republic (from the end of the 1980´s to the spring of 2002) |
2001:12 Who´s afraid of Hierarchies? The Legacy of the Communist Government |
2001:11 11th September. International On-line Communication Research |
2001:10 Fertility and Family Differentiation in Europe |
2001:09 The rise or decline of political regionalism? Changes of voting patterns in period 1992 to 1998 - the comparison of the Czech Republic and Slovakia |
2001:08 Cross-cutting Cleavages in the Czech Republic. A Comparison of the National Level with a Specific Regional Example |
2001:07 Roma Issues: An Obstacle to Entry of the Czech Republic into the European Union? |
2001:06 ISSP- The Environment |
2001:05 Distribution of Earnings and Income in Transitional Czech Republic |
2001:04 The Bearers of Development of the Cross-Border Community on Czech-German Border |
2001:03 Rent Subsidies in the Czech Republic: A Comparison of Selected Models |
2001:02 The Role Of Political, Social and Cultural Capital in Secondary School Selection in Socialist Czechoslovakia, 1948-1989 |
2001:01 Income maintenance policies, houshold characteristics and work incentives in the Czech republic |
2000:07 Work and Family Experience of Young Female Doctors |
2000:06 Development of the Czech Social Structure in the Years 1988-1999 |
2000:05 Party identifikation in the Czech republic |
2000:04 What makes inequalities legitimate? An International Comparison |
2000:03 Religion and Supernature in Society |
2000:02 Transformation and Modernization of Society on Examples of Selected Institutions |
2000:01 The Housing Policy Changes and Housing Expenditures in the Czech Republic |
1999:11 Geografic Analysis of the Czech Republic Borderland. |
1999:10 Rise and Decline of Right-Wing Extremism in the Czech Republic in the 1990s. |
1999:09 Perceived and fair inequalities: development in the nineties and further coherences |
1999:08 The Czechoslovak citizens' attitudes towards democracy in 1968 |
1999:07 The Czech Middletown Citizens |
1999:06 A Man in a Family – Democratisation of Private Sphere |
1999:05 Development of the Policy of Equal Opportunities of Men and Women in the Czech Republic within the European Integration Context |
1999:04 Actors of Over-frontier Community Development in the Czech - German Borderland |
1999:03 Acquaintances of Local Political Leaders |
1999:02 Housing Market, its Regional Differences and Relations to Social Structure |
1999:01 The Fluctuation of Public Opinion between Years 1990 and 1998 |
1998:06 Modernizační kontext transformace, strukturní a institucionální aspekty |
1998:05 Deputies of the First Czech Parliament (1992-1996) |
1998:04 |
1998:03 Transformation of Czech Family |
1998:02 Results of a Czech-Slovak Comparison: Actors of Social Transformation and Modernisation. Attitudes of Individuals an Institutions to Social Transformation |
1998:01 Trh s bydlením a jeho sociální souvislosti - situace v Praze a Brně |
1997:08 The Family and Change of Gender Roles |
1997:07 The territorial dimension of public administration reforms in East Central Europe |
1997:06 Czech Women in the Labor Market Work and Family in a Transition Economy |
1997:05 |
1997:04 Mass Privatization, Distributive Politics, and Popular Support for Reform in the Czech Republic |
1997:03 |
1997:02 |
1997:01 Political, Organizational and Policy Transformation at the Municipal Level: The Case of Liberec |
1996:12 Osidlování českého pohraničí od května 1945 |
1996:11 Individuální kontakty obyvatel na česko-německé hranici |
1996:10 Socio-Economic Changes in the Czech Republic with an Appendix concerning the 1996 Elections´ Results |
1996:09 Národní identita |
1996:08 Politics, Skills and Industrial Restructuring. Introductory Findings on Local Institutions of Human Resources Development in Czech Machinery Indrustry |
1996:07 Subjective Mobility and Perception of Life Chances in Eastern Europe. Empirical evidence against a Marxist view of relationships between subjective and objective mobility |
1996:06 Zpráva o vývoji sociální struktury české a slovenské společnosti 1945-1993 |
1996:05 Tripartita jako model prostředkování zájmů v politickém systému České republiky |
1996:04 Národnostní a etnické vztahy v českém pohraničí - obraz Čecha, Němce, Rakušana a Roma ve vědomí obyvatel |
1996:03 The Making of Post-Communist Elites in Eastern Europe. A comparison of political and economic elites in the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland |
1996:02 Sudetoněmecká otázka v názorech a postojích obyvatel českého pohraničí |
1996:01 Demografické chování obyvatelstva České republiky během přeměny společnosti po roce 1989 |
1995:08 Česká republika v roce 1994. Politická ročenka |
1995:07 Problém normativity a policejní represe v předlistopadovém Československu |
1995:06 Industriální vztahy a sociálně politické orientace českých dělníků a manažerů |
1995:05 Rozdíly v chování regionálních populací a jejich příčiny |
1995:04 Women, Work and Society |
1995:03 Trh práce a jeho potenciál |
1995:02 Etnické a národnostní vztahy v pánevní oblasti severních Čech (s důrazem na romskou problematiku) |
1995:01 In Search of Explanations for Recent Left-Turns in Post-Communist Coutries |
1994:09 Česká republika v roce 1993. Politická ročenka |
1994:08 Large-Scale Privatization: Social Conflict and Consensus |
1994:07 Economic Inequalities Old and New: The Czech Case |
1994:06 Prostředky kauzálního modelování v sociologii. Shrnující pojednání o postupech a přehled základních pojmů |
1994:05 Regionální diferenciace sociálních problémů v České republice |
1994:04 A Historical Comparison of Social Structures in the Czech Republic in 1984 and 1993 |
1994:03 Přeshraniční souvislosti sociálních změn v oblasti české části euroregionu Chebsko |
1994:02 Social and Political Transformation in the Czech Republic |
1994:01 Lotus Organizátor. Uživatelská příručka |
1993:09 Sociální a mzdové problémy zaměstnanců malých a středních soukromých podniků |
1993:08 Sociální postavení rodiny jako základního činitele a adresáta sociální pomoci |
1993:07 Changing Conditions - Changing Values? Changes in the position and perception of education during the post-communist transformation: the case of the Czech Republic |
1993:06 Perceptions of Justice. Principles of Distributive Justice in Comparative Perspective |
1993:04 Revolution for Whom? Analysis of selected patterns of intragenerational mobility in the Czech Republic |
1993:04 Revolution for Whom? Analysis of selected patterns of intragenerational mobility in the Czech Republic |
1993:03 RODINA ´89. Determinanty ekonomického úspěchu v první fázi postkomunistické transformace. Česká republika 1989-1992 |
1993:02 RODINA '89. Determinanty ekonomického úspěchu v první fázi post-komunistické transformace. Česká republika 1989-1992 |
1993:01 Microsoft Word verze 5.5. Uživatelská příručka |
1992:09 Historical Comparison of Social Stratification Types in Czechoslovakia 1967-1991 |
1992:08 Rodina '89. Úloha mentálních schopností a sociálního původu ve formování vzdělanostních aspirací |
1992:07 The Zero Generation of Small Business Owners in Czechoslovakia |
1992:06 Time Use of Small Business Owners. Results and Methodological Comments |
1992:05 Perception of Changing Inequality in Czechoslovakia |
1992:04 Vybrané kapitoly z uživatelské příručky Microsoft Word verze 5.0 |
1992:03 Politické strany a hnutí v Československu |
1992:02 Politische Partien und Bewegungen in der Tschechoslowakei |
Prague in the New Central Europe. International conference 2-4 June 1990 |
1991:09 Vybrané kapitoly z uživatelské příručky Microsoft Word verze 5.0 |
1991:08 Nultá podnikatelská generace |
1991:07 Rodina '89. Zdroje vzdělanostních nerovností |
1991:06 Hodnotové orientace československé mužské mládeže a jejich vztah k obraně vlasti |
1991:05 Gender and the Employment of Higher Education Graduates in Czechoslovakia |
1991:04 Územní vztahy, územní a státoprávní uspořádání České republiky v názorech obyvatel |
1991:03 Social Problems of Participation in the Changing Czechoslovak Economy |
1991:02 K postavení žen v československé společnosti |
1991:01 Socialist Czechoslovakia - System Error and Premises for Change |
1990:06 Názory na rozvoj soukromého podnikání |
1990:05 Growing interest in informal work - consequences for time use research. XIIth World Congress of Sociology, Madrid 1990, Thematic Group 1, Time Use Research |
1990:04 Value-satisfaction Model and the Value of Innovation |
1990:03 Who Gains and Who Loses in a Socialist Redistribution |
1990:02 Ženy a volby '90 |
1990:01 Beyond Educational Inequality in Czechoslovakia |
1989:02 Československá varianta Mezinárodní standardní klasifikace zaměstnání (ISCO) |
1989:01 Family Effect on Educational Attainment in Czechoslovakia, Hungary and the Netherlands |
|
|