Sociologický časopis / Czech Sociological Review 2018, 54(6): 907-932 | DOI: 10.13060/00380288.2018.54.6.435

Hybrid Warriors: Transforming Czech Security through the 'Russian Hybrid Warfare' Assemblage

Jan Daniel, Jakub Eberle
Institute of International Relations, Prague

This article analyses the ascent of 'Russian hybrid warfare' (RHW) as a notion that transformed the understanding of national security in the Czech Republic in the short period of 2014-2016. It argues that the emergence of RHW as a specifically understood prime security threat was the result of contingent and often unruly social interactions across different settings, rather than a linear and centralised response to Russia's actions. To capture this process, the concept of 'assemblage' is introduced and then defined as a temporary constellation of a variety of different actors, both public and private. Building on research interviews and documents produced in the RHW field, the authors then proceed in three steps. First, they chronologically trace the gradual emergence of the Czech RHW assemblage from a variety of different actors-bureaucrats, NGOs, academics, journalists-after Russia's attack on Ukraine in 2014. Second, they unpack the inner workings of the assemblage by identifying the key actors and asking who did the assembling and how. Third, they look at how different actors were able to reinforce and/or transform their identities by being part of the assemblage, with an emphasis on the effects this had for the distinction between the public and the private.

Keywords: hybrid warfare, disinformation, assemblage, Russia, Czech Republic

Published: December 1, 2018Show citation

ACS AIP APA ASA Harvard Chicago IEEE ISO690 MLA NLM Turabian Vancouver
Daniel, J., & Eberle, J. (2018). Hybrid Warriors: Transforming Czech Security through the 'Russian Hybrid Warfare' Assemblage. Sociologický časopis / Czech Sociological Review54(6), 907-932. doi: 10.13060/00380288.2018.54.6.435.
Download citation

References

  1. Abrahamsen, R. and M. C. Williams. 2011. Security Beyond the State: Private Security in International Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Go to original source...
  2. Acuto, M. and S. Curtis (eds). 2014. Reassembling International Theory: Assemblage Thinking and International Relations. Houndsmill: Palgrave Macmillan, https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137383969. Go to original source...
  3. BBC. 2013. 'Nato Summit to Be Held in September, PM Cameron Tweets.' BBC, 15 November. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-politics-24959471).
  4. Berling, T. V. 2015. The International Political Sociology of Security: Rethinking Theory and Practice. New York: Routledge, https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315722375. Go to original source...
  5. Bigo, D. 2013. 'Security.' Pp. 114-130 in Bourdieu in International Relations: Rethinking Key Concepts in IR, edited by R. Adler-Nissen. London: Routledge.
  6. Bigo, D. 2014. 'The (In)securitization Practices of the Three Universes of EU Border Control: Military/Navy-Border Guards/Police-Database Analysts.' Security Dialogue 45 (3): 209-225, https://doi.org/10.1177/0967010614530459. Go to original source...
  7. Börzel, T. 1998. 'Organizing Babylon-On the Different Conceptions of Policy Networks.' Public Administration 76 (2): 253-273, https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9299.00100. Go to original source...
  8. Bueger, C. 2018. 'Territory, Authority, Expertise: Global Governance and the CounterPiracy Assemblage.' European Journal of International Relations 24 (3): 614-637, https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1354066117725155. Go to original source...
  9. Buzan, B., J. Waever and J. de Wilde. 1998. Security: A New Framework for Analysis. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
  10. Campbell, D. 1998. Writing Security: United States Foreign Policy and the Politics of Identity. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
  11. Charap, S. 2015. 'The Ghost of Hybrid War.' Survival 57 (6): 51-58, https://doi.org/10.1080/00396338.2015.1116147. Go to original source...
  12. Czech News Agency. 2015. 'Sobotka požádal ministra vnitra o bezpečnostní audit ČR.' (Sobotka asked the Minister of Interior for a security audit of the Czech Republic) Lidovky.cz, 22 November. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.lidovky.cz/sobotka-pozadal-ministra-vnitra-o-bezpecnostni-audit-cr-pkj-/zpravy-domov.aspx).
  13. Dittmer, J. 2017. Diplomatic Material: Affect, Assemblage, and Foreign Policy. Durham: Duke University Press, https://doi.org/10.1215/9780822372745. Go to original source...
  14. Echo24. 2014. '"Akce proti Zemanovi řídily USA." Ruská propaganda jede, uvěřil i Huml' (The actions against Zeman were directed by the USA.' Russian propaganda works, even Huml fell for it) Echo24. 19 November. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://echo24.cz/a/wcgTt/akce-proti-zemanovi-ridily-usa-ruska-propaganda-jedeuveril-i-huml).
  15. European Values. 2017a. 'Kremlin Watch.' Evropské hodnoty, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/kremlinwatch).
  16. European Values. 2017b. 'Akce-2016.' (Events-2016) Evropské hodnoty, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/akce/2016).
  17. European Values. 2017c. 'Stratcom Summit 2016.' European Values, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.europeanvalues.net/kremlinwatch/stratcomsummit-2016).
  18. European Values. 2017d. 'Role médií v ruské dezinformační kampani.' (The role of the media in the Russian disinformation campaign) Evropské hodnoty, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/akce/role-medii-v-ruskedezinformacni-kampani).
  19. European Values. 2017e. 'Výroční zpráva 2014.' (Annual Report 2014) Evropské hodnoty, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/EH_VZ_2014_final_web.pdf).
  20. European Values. 2017f. 'Výroční zpráva za 2016.' (Annual Report for 2016) Evropské hodnoty, undated, Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/EH_VZ_2016.compressed.pdf).
  21. Fojtů, M. 2016. 'Jsme v informační válce s Ruskem, i když jsme si to nevybrali.' (We are in an information war with Russia even though we didn't choose to be) online.muni.cz, 27 April. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.online.muni.cz/udalosti/7562-jsme-v-informacni-valce-s-ruskem-i-kdyz-jsme-si-to-nevybrali).
  22. Haas, P. 1992. 'Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy Coordination.' International Organization 46 (1):1-35, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020818300001442. Go to original source...
  23. Howlett, M. and M. Ramesh. 2003. Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems. New York: Oxford University Press.
  24. Golis, O. 2016. 'Všechny fake news nelze odhalit, mají faktický základ a působí věrohodně, varuje odborník.' (Not all fake news can be uncovered, it is based in fact and looks trustworthy, one expert warns) iRozhlas, 2 December. Retrieved 11 June 2018 (https://www.irozhlas.cz/zpravy-domov/vsechny-fake-news-nelzeodhalit-maji-fakticky-zaklad-a-pusobi-verohodne-varuje-odbornik-_201612020555_ ogolis).
  25. Gregor, M. and P. Vejvodová. 2016. 'Analýza manipulativních technik na vybraných českých serverech.' (An analysis of manipulation techniques on selected Czech servers) Evropské hodnoty, 12 June. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Vyzkumna_zprava_Analyza_manipulativnich.pdf).
  26. Janda, J. 2016. 'How the West Can Beat Back the Kremlin.' Atlantic Council, 20 December. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.atlanticcouncil.org/component/content/article?id=33739:how-the-west-can-beat-back-the-kremlin).
  27. Janda, J. 2017. 'Jak jsme v Česku začali budovat obranný val proti nepřátelskému vlivu Kremlu.' (How we started to build a defence wall against the hostile influence of the Kremlin in the Czech Republic) Evropské Hodnoty, 28 February. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/jak-jsme-v-cesku).
  28. Janda, J. and O. Kundra. 2016. 'Schéma fungování vlivu Ruské federace v České republice.' (Diagram of the Russian Federation's influence in the Czech Republic) Evropské hodnoty, 16 August. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/SCH%C3%89MAFUNGOV%C3%81N%C3%8D-VLIVU-RUSK%C3%89-FEDERACE-V%C4%8CESK%C3%89-REPUBLICE1.pdf).
  29. Kovanda, O. 2018. 'Hybridní válka? Buďme s tím označením opatrní, radí experti.' (Hybrid war? Careful with that label, experts advise) Idnes.cz, 18 January. Retrieved 20 June 2018 (https://zpravy.idnes.cz/hybridni-valka-rozhovor-eberle-daniel-ruskofme-/zpr_nato.aspx?c=A180118_094512_zpr_nato_inc).
  30. Krejčí, M. 2016. 'Proč jsme v Česku náchylní k propagandě?' (Why are we in the Czech Republic susceptible to propaganda) Evopské hodnoty, 28 April. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.evropskehodnoty.cz/proc-jsme-v-cesku-nachylni-k-propagande).
  31. Kříž, Z., Z. Schevchuk and P. Števkov. 2015. Hybrid Warfare: A New Phenomenon in Europe's Security Environment. Prague, Ostrava: Jagello 2000. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://data.idnes.cz/soubory/na_knihovna/74A151130_M02_021_20151126-HYBRID-WA.PDF).
  32. Kubeša, M. and J. Spišák. 2011. 'Hybrid Threats and the Development of NATO's New Operational Concept.' Obrana a Strategie 11 (2): 5-16, https://doi.org/10.3849/1802-7199.11.2011.02.005-016. Go to original source...
  33. Kundra, O. 2015. 'Putinův hlas v Česku.' (Putin's voice in the Czech Republic) Respekt (10), 2 March 2015.
  34. Kundra, O. 2016a. Putinovi agenti. (Putin's agents) Brno: BizBooks.
  35. Kundra, O. 2016b. 'Kdo tu píše pro Putina.' (Who here is writing for Putin) Respekt (18), 2 May 2016.
  36. Lang, V. 2015. 'Pocit bezpečí je iluze, v podstatě už jsme ve válce, varovali čeští odborníci.' (The feeling of security is an illusion, we are in essence already at war, Czech experts have warned) Novinky.cz, 17 February. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.novinky.cz/domaci/361924-pocit-bezpeci-je-iluze-v-podstate-uz-jsmeve-valce-varovali-cesti-odbornici.html).
  37. Loughlan, V., C. Olsson and P. Schouten. 2015. 'Mapping.' Pp. 23-56 in Critical Security Methods: New frameworks for analysis, edited by C. Aradau, J. Huysmans, A. Neal and N. Voelkner. London and New York: Routledge.
  38. Marcussen, M. and J. Torfing. 2007. Democratic Network Governance in Europe. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230596283. Go to original source...
  39. May, J. and A. Wildavsky (eds). 1978. The Policy Cycle. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
  40. Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA). 2015a. 'Vláda aktualizovala Bezpečnostní strategii České republiky.' (The government has updated the Security Strategy of the Czech Republic) Ministerstvo zahraničních věcí České republiky, 4 February. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.mzv.cz/jnp/cz/udalosti_a_media/archiv_zprav/rok_2015/tiskove_zpravy/x2015_02_04_vlada_aktualizovala_bezpecnostni_strategii. html).
  41. Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA). 2015b. Security Strategy of the Czech Republic. Prague: Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Czech Republic.
  42. Ministry of Defence (MoD). 2014. 'S čím pojede Česko na summit NATO-Martin Stropnický hostem Interview ČT24.' (What will the Czech position be at the NATO summit-Martin Stropnický as a guest on Czech Television 24's Interview programme) Ministerstvo obrany České republiky, 1 September. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.mocr.army.cz/informacni-servis/forum/s-cim-pojede-cesko-nasummit-nato - martin-stropnicky-hostem-interview-ct24-101425).
  43. Ministry of the Interior (MoI). 2015. 'Extremismus: Souhrnná situační zpráva 3.čtvrtletí roku 2015.' (Extremism: Summary situation report for the third quarter of 2015) Ministerstvo vnitra České republiky, 20 October, Retrieved 7 November 2017' (http://www.mvcr.cz/soubor/souhrnna-situacni-zprava-za-3-ctvrtleti-roku-2015.aspx).
  44. Ministry of the Interior (MoI). 2016. National Security Audit. Ministry of the Interior of the Czech Republic: Prague.
  45. Müller, M. 2015. 'Assemblages and Actor-Networks: Rethinking Socio-Material Power, Politics and Space: Assemblages and Actor-Networks.' Geography Compass 9 (1): 27-41, https://doi.org/10.1111/gec3.12192. Go to original source...
  46. Natoaktual.cz. 2018. 'Projekty uskutečněné v roce 2016.' (Projects conducted in 2016) Natoaktual.cz, undated. Retrieved 11 June 2018 (http://www.natoaktual.cz/projektyic-nato-2016-0a9-/na_projekty.aspx?y=na_projekty/projekty-ic-nato-2016.htm).
  47. Neovlivni.cz. 2016. 'Databáze proruského obsahu od A-Z.' (A database of pro-Russian content from A to Z) Neovlivni.cz, 7 November. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.pssi.cz/russia-s-influence-activities-in-cee/economic-relations-betweenthe-visegrad-countries-and-russia).
  48. Nováková, L. 2016a. 'Premiér a ministr vnitra představili finální text Auditu národní bezpečnosti.' (The Prime Minister and Interior Minister introduced the final text of the National Security Audit) Ministerstvo vnitra České republiky, 1 December. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.mvcr.cz/clanek/premier-a-ministr-vnitra-predstavilifinalni-text-auditu-narodni-bezpecnosti.aspx).
  49. Nováková, L. 2016b. 'Premiér s ministrem vnitra představili první návrhy Auditu národní bezpečnosti.' (The Prime Minister and Interior Minister presented the first proposals of the National Security Audit) Ministerstvo vnitra České republiky, 12 May. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.mvcr.cz/clanek/premier-s-ministrem-vnitrapredstavili-prvni-navrhy-auditu-narodni-bezpecnosti.aspx).
  50. Ong, A. and S. Collier (eds). 2005. Global Assemblages: Technology, Politics, and Ethics as Anthropological Problems. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing.
  51. PSSI. 2015. 'The Pro-Russian Disinformation Campaign in the Czech Republic and Slovakia.' Prague Security Studies Institute, 9 June. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.pssi.cz/publications/39-the-pro-russian-disinformation-campaign-inthe-czech-republic-and-slovakia.htm).
  52. PSSI. 2017a. 'About Us.' Prague Security Studies Institute, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.pssi.cz/about-us).
  53. PSSI. 2017b. 'Economic Relations between the Visegrad Countries and Russia: Before and After Ukraine.' Prague Security Studies Institute, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.pssi.cz/russia-s-influence-activities-in-cee/economic-relations-betweenthe-visegrad-countries-and-russia).
  54. PSSI. 2017c. 'Raising Awareness of Russian Soft Power in Central Europe.' Prague Security Studies Institute, undated. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.pssi.cz/russias-influence-activities-in-cee/assessment-of-kremlin-s-soft-power-tools-in-centraleurope).
  55. Řehka, K. 2015. 'Válka, jak ji (ne)známe. Nekonvenční vedení války: kde začíná, kdy si ho všimneme a jak se můžeme bránit?' (War as we (don't) know it. Unconventional warfare: where does it start, how can we recognise it, and how can we counter it) Pp. 206-229 in Povaha změny: Bezpečnost, rizika a stav dnešní civilizace, edited by M. Bárta, O. Foltýn and M. Kovář. Prague: Vyšehrad.
  56. Renz, B. 2016. 'Russia and "Hybrid Warfare".' Contemporary Politics 22 (3): 283-300, https://doi.org/10.1080/13569775.2016.1201316. Go to original source...
  57. Rhodes, R. W. and D. Marsh. 1992. 'New Directions in the Study of Policy Networks.' European Journal of Political Research 21 (1-2): 181-205, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-6765.1992.tb00294.x. Go to original source...
  58. Sassen, S. 2006. Territory, Authority, Rights: From Medieval to Global Assemblages. Princeton, NJ, and Oxford: Princeton University Press.
  59. Ševela, V. 2014. 'Dokonale utajený server. Kdo vydává proruské zprávy v češtině.' (A perfectly covert server. Who publishes Czech pro-Russian news) Echo24, 8 August. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://echo24.cz/a/i9gac/dokonale-utajeny-server-kdovydava-proruske-zpravy-v-cestine).
  60. SIS. 2015. 'Annual Report of the Security Information Service for 2014.' Bezpečnostní informační služba, 4 September. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.bis.cz/vyrocni-zpravaEN6c8d.html?ArticleID=1096).
  61. Smoleňová, I. 2015a. 'Russia's Propaganda War.' Forbes, 25 March. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2015/03/25/russias-propagandawar).
  62. Smoleňová, I. 2015b. 'Proruské weby začali vznikať pred 10 rokmi. Dnes sú však agresívnejšie.' (Pro-Russian websites started to emerge 10 years ago. Nowadays, they are more aggressive) Denník N, 24 March. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2015/03/25/russias-propaganda-war).
  63. Smoleňová, I. 2016. 'Proruská desinformační kampaň v České republice a na Slovensku.' (The pro-Russian disinformation campaign in the Czech Republic and Slovakia) PSSI, August 2016. Retrieved 11 June 2018 (http://www.pssi.cz/download/docs/355_desinformacni-kampan-pssi.pdf).
  64. Sørensen, E. and J. Torfing. 2007. 'Theoretical Approaches to Governance Network Dynamics.' Pp. 25-42 in Theories of Democratic Network Governance, edited by E. Sørensen and J. Torfing. London: Palgrave Macmillan, https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230625006_2. Go to original source...
  65. Světnička, L. 2015a. 'Ruské dezinformace zaplavují Česko a zamlžují pravdu, tvrdí analytička.' (Russian disinformation is flooding the Czech Republic and blurring the truth, analyst claims) Idnes.cz, 20 June. Retrieved 11 June 2018 (https://zpravy.idnes.cz/rusko-zaplavuje-evropu-i-cesko-dezinformacemi-flc-/zpr_nato.aspx?c=A150619_171622_zpr_nato_inc).
  66. Světnička, L. 2015b. 'Hybridní válce se musí bránit celá společnost. I česká, tvrdí experti.' (Hybrid warfare has to be countered by the whole society. Even the Czech one, experts claim) Idnes.cz, 15 July. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://zpravy.idnes.cz/eperti-chteji-popsat-hybridni-boj-dlv-/zpr_nato.aspx?c=A150715_134014_zpr_nato_ inc).
  67. Torfing, J. 2007. 'Introduction: Democratic Network Governance.' Pp. 1-22 in Democratic Network Governance in Europe, edited by M. Marcussen and J. Torfing. London: Palgrave Macmillan, https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230596283_1. Go to original source...
  68. Zaorálek, L. and P. Drulák. 2014. 'Probuďme naši zahraniční politiku.' (Let's revive our foreign policy) Ústav mezinárodních vztahů, 10 January. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (http://www.iir.cz/article/probudme-nasi-zahranicni-politiku).
  69. Zeman, M. 2016. 'Vánoční poselství prezidenta republiky Miloše Zemana.' (Christmas message from the President of the Republic Miloš Zeman) Novinky.cz, 26 December. Retrieved 7 November 2017 (https://www.novinky.cz/specialy/dokumenty/424659dokument-vanocni-poselstvi-prezidenta-milose-zemana.html).
  70. Zůna, P. 2010. 'Kritický pohled na koncept hybridních válek.' (A critical look at the concept of hybrid wars) Vojenské Rozhledy 19 (3): 33-45.

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0), which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original publication is properly cited. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.